Security Trimming Bug ? WSS3.0

I have a strange one that I noticed today and thought someone might have seen it, have an answer, etc.

We have a WSS3.0 Site Collection that we are using for the IT department at my client site to collaborate (I'm working on getting MOSS but for now, they are getting their feet wet with WSS)

I created a site under the root site of the site collection (Home > Secure Site) and removed permissions for everyone except a few folks. This worked fine and all users except those few do not have the menu item displayed to them. Great.

What I noticed is, if another user is the Site Owner of a sub site (Home > Another Site) then when they are on the site that they are an owner of, they see the link in the menu bar for the Secure Site. Granted that when they click on it, they get a security error so there is no information disclosure but it is annoying as one of the compelling features of WSS 3 vs 2 is the security trimmed interface.

Is the security trimming not applied to ANY items if you own a site Is this a known bug




Answer this question

Security Trimming Bug ? WSS3.0

  • Buddy

    Thanks for at least doing a snity check.. looks liek the security trimming for the built in menu has a bug

  • Azimuth

    BUMP... Can someone try to reproduce this on thier end I am seeing it in two different installations and I think it is a bug... Please... anyone :-)

  • esafari68

    ANyone, ANyone.. going once.. going twice ;-)

  • yogamnandhu

    I am having the same issue and the senior management isn't very happy about it because they don't want people to see their tab and them be denied access. Could some one from Microsoft please verify it this is a bug and if there are any plans for it to be fixed
  • oilyneck

    I have experienced similar behaviour. I am a site owner of one sub-site.

    When I click on the site that I own, I suddenly see tabs to other sub-sites. When I try to click on those sub-sites, I get Access is Denied.

    When I am in a different area than my sub-site, then I do NOT see those other tabs.

    Seems like a bug to me.

    - Libby



  • JonesAtl

    I can't believe that Microsoft hasn't confirmed or denied this. It is obviously a bug :-(

  • Tryin2Bgood

    Can someone tell me if this is unique to my installation or if it is a bug in the product

    Should I post this in another forum I loked at the categories and this seemed like the best fit :-)



  • Security Trimming Bug ? WSS3.0